If we made a VCA in 1U, what are the essential features you would like to have on it?
Keep in mind we would like to try and keep each 1U module as small as possible.
For example we could make a full featured dual VCA like the uVCA but in 1U specs this would be a quite massive module and therefore not the best idea.
It is also an opportunity to do something a little different than we would in 3U.
One possibility is to make a stereo VCA that has a single set of controls (e.g. one CV knob and jack but stereo i/o)
The smallest module would be single or dual linear VCA with only jacks and no bias knob or attenuator.
One feature I would definitely discount immediately is lin vs. log. I think it is better to leave these as linear only VCAs. A bigger debate would be whether or not to include both CV attenuator and bias/level knob.
Any feedback greatly appreciated! We will definitely make a VCA module if we can get a good consensus on desired features.
otherwise…in the modular spirit of things, dig the idea of it basically being 1/2 of a µVCA, especially if it would keep the price down, so if people wanted to grab a couple, it wouldn’t break the bank. i would personally want cv att AND bias, but i can see the advantage of jack only, both from a cost and space pov.
I think this is a great idea, however would encourage the implementation of an attenuator. It removes the need to redirect the signal through an attenuator prior. Even with 9mm pots, that is better than none.
A simple idea / sketch. Single VCA, with dual cv attenuation
a tiny simple dual VCA with no attenuation makes sense. Keep it small so i can fit it in with my 2 quadratts, lineout, and headphones. I’d like it to be optionally dual instead of always stereo if possible
If its a 2 channel VCA controlled with one source , then have a little switch to invert the CV of channel 2 to create ducking effects or VC crossfade 2 signals.
In my opinion every linear VCA should just be a crossfader, cuz every VCA is already a crippled crossfader, crippled in the sense that you can only crossfade with silence ie:turn the signal down. being able to have control over what that “silence” is, is a good simple feature.
My primary request is that it should be possible to fully open the VCA with a 5V signal, and provide an attenuator to tame/limit hot control signals. This would allow more control sources to affect the entire range of the VCA.
Quite a few of the basic VCAs on the market require 10V to fully open, so if one is using e.g. a Doepfer type EG (0-8V) then it’s not possible to fully open the VCA unless some amplification is used to boost the EG output, which frankly is a bit naff.
A simple dual vca kinda design gives some good opportunity for using logic to give different uses. I like the crossfader idea a lot, a simple crossfader is an easy way to get musical expression in a very small space. I would definitely get that
Also a fan of how the vcas are implemented in IFM Denum/Dunst. Two vcas and the difference between the modulation voltage on each channel decides which output and how much gain per output.