Invariably, tastes will change with time, and sure, there is some “herd mentality” factor there. However, the whole notion of a modular format with some sort of compatibility standard, is that artists can mix and match components from different manufacturers to create whatever audio system they want or need. Subsequently, if manufacturers refuse to conform to a single aesthetic standard (boy, that ship has sailed), then everyone’s modular systems necessarily become more of a stylistic hodgepodge as they expand. Sure, there are those few that build single manufacturer systems, but they are obviously in the extreme minority, as are those that have the resources to manufacture their own custom panels.
Many don’t mind the clash of panel styles, but a good number of us (myself included) attempt to maintain some sort of visual continuity in order to at least create the sense of a single custom instrument. Because manufacturers have long since abandoned a single uniform panel style, the only hope for those of us chasing visual continuity is that manufacturers offer various panel options.
Offering panel options is clearly more expensive for the manufacturers. These days it seems that manufacturers can please most customers by simply offering a choice of black or white/light gray (2HP, Qu-Bit, Doepfer, EMW, Happy Nerding, Schlappi, Synth Tech). Some offset the expense by offering replacement panels at additional cost (4MS, XAOC). A precious few (ADDAC, Ladik) accept custom orders for almost any panel color, but again requiring an additional fee.
It isn’t about following the herd or jumping on the band wagon (for most of us).
I believe offering panel options is in the best spirit of modular, allowing customers to build a system that not only operates the way they want, but looks the way they want. Manufacturers that limit their panel options necessarily limit their customer base. Offering options doesn’t have to be more expensive for the manufacturer, as most customers don’t mind paying the extra fee for a replacement panel if it is important to them. Offering options does require some extra effort in logistics and bookkeeping, but expanding one’s customer base seems like it would be worth the trade off.
While that is true, the argument seems specious as it also applies just as much to white/gray panels. White Intellijel panels don’t match white NLC panels, either. Honestly, I don’t think most eurorack enthusiasts expect perfect uniformity. The vast majority requesting panel options are really just looking for a modicum of visual continuity in their eurorack systems.
Thanks for your time and consideration.